• Home
  • Dharma Talk with Kanho Chris Burkhart - Ancestors and Teachers Part 1

Dharma Talk with Kanho Chris Burkhart - Ancestors and Teachers Part 1

  • Wednesday, November 11, 2026
  • 7:00 PM - 7:30 PM
  • Sansui-ji Temple


Stream audio:



Stream video:

Talk Notes

It's been a while since I gave my last Dharma talk. A lot has happened in the meantime. I was able to be in California for three weeks to assist my teacher during a series of ceremonies, which was wonderful. And I came home a little bit early because my partner was really sick, which was not so wonderful. And that got even worse when he had a stroke two days after I arrived back at home. So I'm really engaged with visiting him down in Sedro-Woolley. So four hours of the day are gone that way. So I decided to start writing this Dharma talk early so I could spend a good amount of time with it. The drawback is that it got like way too long and I spent like the last hour today cutting out some bits and pieces. But so I'm hoping that the Ino is going to give me a nod or throw something at me 10 minutes before I'm supposed to end. I'm hoping that maybe we can squeeze in a little bit of time for triads after, but I wouldn't bet on it tonight.

So this is going to be talk number one of a series of talks on ancestors and teachers and they're going to be interspersed between the regular dharma seminars into next year.

So we bow to the Buddha. We bow to our cushions. We bow to one another. And in some ceremonies, we chant the names of our ancestors. And whoever the doshi is bows a lot. We tell the names of our ancestors going back through the generations through Japan, China and India all the way back to Shakyamuni Buddha. You recite names that may be difficult to to pronounce and that mean absolutely nothing to us.

Some of those people died hundreds of years ago. Some we know a lot about, some very little. And yet we acknowledge them as our ancestors, as the people through whom the dharma has come down to us. And sometimes I wonder whether we should like slow down a little and think about what we actually say, who we name Why do we remember them? And who are these people? And what does it mean to call someone a Dharma ancestor? And where did they leave all the women? And where are the teachers whose lineages were wiped out by wars and by famine? So again today we are beginning a series of talks about Zen ancestors and teachers. Over the coming months we will meet some remarkable people, some famous, some almost forgotten, some wise and some definitely shall I call it eccentric.

There will be men and women.

Some left behind extensive writings like Dogen and some are remembered for a single encounter, for their awakening, for a gesture or a few words. So what I find interesting is not necessarily what they taught, but how they're teaching continues to speak to us. We're not studying ancient history for its own sake. And we'll get to that a little bit later. It's not actual history. But we are interested in how the dharma comes alive in our own lives here and now.

But before I begin meeting individual ancestors, I would like to look at the whole idea of ancestors and lineage. Zen has a rather peculiar relationship with its history. On one hand, Zen emphasizes direct experience. Just now, just this warns us against becoming attached to words and scriptures and insists that awakening cannot be reduced to concepts. On the other hand, Zen has developed elaborate systems and rituals, ancestral succession complete with transmission documents, ceremonies and stories of awakening passed from teacher to student.

Sometimes there seems to be an almost obsessive interest in who received transmission from whom and how did it happen and history sometimes says that chronologically the lineage we have is impossible. So what are we actually preserving?

In the earliest Buddhist community, the Buddha taught monks and nuns, layman and lay women, women of different social classes and backgrounds. Some became accomplished teachers themselves. There was communal recitation, memorization, practice and after quite some time written collections. There were respected elders and lines of patriarchs that we find in later Zen histories. The Buddha did not establish a school with a formal lineage.

In fact, as he was dying, he did not name a direct successor.

When Buddhism entered China, it encountered a culture in which ancestry, family relationships, and the continuity of generations carried enormous significance. Confusian traditions emphasized respect for parents and ancestors and a person's place was in an extended family was an important part of social and moral life.

Buddhism with its celibate monastics who left their families initially appeared rather strange to many Chinese observers. Of course, over time, China adapted quite well to this by basically establishing a family relationship between teacher and student. Teachers became dharma parents, mostly fathers, let's be honest. Students became dharma heirs or dharma sons. It was not simply a matter of borrowing Chinese family customs. Buddhist traditions already valued the teachers and the relationship to their students, warm hand to warm hand.

But in China, the idea of an ancestral lineage became central to religious identity.

One of the best known stories in our Zen tradition is the story of the flower sermon. According to the traditional account, the Buddha one day instead of giving giving a dharma talk held up the flower, didn't say a word. Everyone was silent, kind of stumped except for Mahākāśyapa. He smiled.

And the Buddha recognized his understanding and entrusted him with a true dharma eye.

Yeah, it's a beautiful story. There is no elaborate explanation. No philosophical argument, just a flower, a smile, and recognition.

It's kind of too bad that this was kind of invented after the fact. It doesn't show up anywhere in the pali cannon, but it's a great story, I think.

This familiar account appears much later in Chinese Chan literature more than a thousand years after the Buddha's lifetime. Mahākāśyapa himself was clearly an important disciple but his role as the first ancestor in an unproven Zen transmission lineage is the later instruction.

The story tells us something about how Zen came to understand itself,

but it's unfortunately not reliable evidence that this sweet event actually took place.

I personally do not think that we need to choose in any way, shape or form between accepting the story as history and dismissing it as worthless. The story can express a religious truth without being an eyewitness account. We can appreciate the raising of the flower and Mahākāśyapa's smile. And we can also acknowledge at the same time that the Buddha probably did not do such a thing.

So as Chan developed in China, different communities claimed different lineages. In the platform sutra, Shenxiu is portrayed as the accomplished monk who writes a verse about polishing the mirror of the mind. While Huineng, an illiterate laborer working in the rice room, responds with a verse denying that there is a mirror to polish. Huineng becomes the sixth ancestor, the bearer of authentic transmission.

Again, it's a wonderful teaching story and one we recently explored. But historically, Shenxiu was an important and highly respected teacher. His tradition was not simply a collection of misguided people who failed to understand awakening. The familiar contrast between gradual and sudden enlightenment was shaped in part by later disputes over religious authority. The winners of the disputes had considerable influence over how the story was remembered. We might ask what Shenxiu himself would have thought of the role he was assigned in the history of Zen.

This is one of the reasons those lineage records are so interesting. Again, they're not history in the modern sense. Especially in India, there was no interest at all in any chronology or history.

The stories are expressions of how particular communities understood their inheritance. They tell us whom those communities recognized and what they valued, how they wish to explain their place in Zen history.

So sometimes the stories they selected tells us a lot about what they believed in and how they compiled it.

So over time, Chinese Chan, Chinese Zen developed an extensive literature of transmission records, often called transmission of the lamp histories. In Japan, Keizan Jōkin, one of the great ancestors in our Soto Zen tradition, presented the lineage in his Denkōroku, the record of the transmission of illumination, also translated as transmission of the light. Keizan lived in the late 13th and early 14th centuries and his work takes us from Shakyamuni Buddha all the way through Dogan's successor Ejo. Each chapter presents an ancestors awakening and Keizan's interpretation of its significance.

We can read the Denkōroku with appreciation and respect without assuming that every detail can be verified historically.

We can allow the stories to teach us while remaining curious about how they developed.

We don't need to defend the tradition against historical inquiry. If the dharma is true, it does not require us to pretend that every story happened exactly the way it was told.

There's another reason that lineage charts cannot give us the complete history. History is not particularly kind to religious institutions. Monastery burned. Libraries were destroyed. Governments changed. Wars and famine interrupted teaching communities. Teachers die without leaving successors. Sometimes the teachings survive, but the institutions that preserved them disappear.

China especially also Japan experienced several major persecutions of Buddhism. The most famous occurred in 845 during the Tang dynasty under Emperor Wuzong. Buddhism had become an enormous religion and economic presence in China. Monasteries owned land and wealth and large numbers of monks and nuns were exempt from the taxes and obligations of ordinary citizens.

Some officials regarded Buddhism as a foreign religion that was not compatible with Chinese tradition. Political, economic, and religious interests combined, and the government ordered the confiscation of monastic property, the closure of thousands of monasteries, and the forced return of large numbers of monastics to lay life. Imagine what that meant for the people living through it. A monastery that had supported generations of practice might disappear in a matter of days.

Scriptures could be lost. Teachers dispersed. Monks ordered to marry. Some traditions recovered. Others never regained their strength.

Community in remote areas sometimes survived when institutions closer to centers of power did not. The continuation of a lineage could depend on geography, political circumstances and sheer good fortune.

Similar processes occurred elsewhere.

Buddhism lost many of the institutions that had supported it for centuries.

Traditions changed, merged, disappeared.

When we look at our lineage chart, we are looking at one surviving thread in an enormously complicated tapestry. One thread. There are numerous other threads, other teachers, other communities, other expressions of awakening.

And many of those disappeared completely from the historical record.

Some are known by some fragments. Some disappeared forever.

Their absence from our chart does not mean that they were not as good as our practice. It doesn't mean that they were less sincere. It just means that they're not around anymore.

And there is another obvious absence. When we look at the traditional lineage chart, we find men.

Generation after generation, Dharma fathers and Dharma sons, patriarchs and successors. Were there no awakened women? Of course there were. The early Buddhist scriptures contain the voices of accomplished nuns and the history of Chinese and Japanese Buddhism includes remarkable women teachers.

But the institutions that preserved and authorized transmission were male and their records reflect that.

I read in a book that had this interesting little blip that when there was a female abbot in later rewriting/recopying of the records that were sometimes turned into men and sometimes their history was just completely written out of history.

Mahāprajāpatī Gautamī, the Buddha's aunt and foster mother, is remembered as the first Buddhist nun and the founder of the women's monastic community. In the earliest Buddhist tradition, the nun Dhammadinnā is celebrated for her extraordinary ability to explain the dharma and her teaching is preserved in the pali cannon. Neither appears in the traditional lineage chart. Much respect to my teacher Norman Fischer who together with other teachers recreated a women's lineage chart, but I think it's pretty specific to Zen center even though it has been adopted by some other communities.

In China, Moshan Liaoran was a Chan teacher who became the teacher of a male monk, Guanzhi Zhixian. According to the traditional account, he recognized the importance of what he had learned from her and acknowledged both his male and female teachers.

Miaoxin, another Chinese woman teacher, was entrusted with important responsibilities in her monastery and demonstrated her understanding when visiting monks became entangled in a discussion of Huineng's famous teaching about the wind, the flag, and the mind. These women were not supporting the practice of men. They were teachers in their own right. And Dogen who we regard as one of the central ancestors of our tradition had something quite forceful to say about this. Bowing to the marrow or receiving the marrow by bowing is the title of the fascicle. Dogen criticizes those who refuse to recognize the dharma authority of women. He insists that when someone has realized the dharma, they should bow to that person regardless whether the teacher is male or female. He recounts examples of women teachers and challenges the assumption that a woman's body is an obstacle to awakening.

Of course, when we speak about teachers and ancestors, we will not ignore women or treat them as an appendix to the history of men. We'll also include teachers who are not in our formal lineage because our interests are not confined by that particular one threat that survived.

We are interested in the people who practice, taught, questioned and embodied the dharma.

And what a collection of characters they are. Huineng, the illiterate wood cutter who became the sixth ancestor. Bodhi Dharma who according to legend faced the wall for nine years.

Zhaozhou or Chao-chou who answered the monk's question about Buddha nature was Mu. Dongshan who saw his reflection in a stream and recognized that he was intimate with the world.

Let's not forget all the women who just showed up as a quick mention as the old tea lady or the seller of rice cakes. Like I said, my dharma talk got too long, so I'm going to cut out the last couple of pages. Just let me read the end. So the most important question is not whether we can trace an absolutely unbroken historical lineage from Shakyamuni Buddha to us. The important question is what are we each and every one of us doing with the dharma that we receive?

Does it help us? What can we learn? Does it help us recognize our own delusions? Are we willing to recognize and accept that each and every one of these teachers was a human being with faults and flaws making mistakes just like us? Does it help us when we meet the world as it is rather than a purified and perfumed history that wasn't quite that way?

Is our dharma alive whenever we wholeheartedly take up the way?

I would say we can always return to our cushion, sit down and practice. The ancestors have done their part. Now it's our turn.

So I really wanted to leave a few minutes so we can speak in quiet maybe on

what we heard tonight. So I thought a couple of appropriate questions might be has there been a teacher in your life who you honor and what did they teach you? I did not say dharma teacher I said teacher did you learn something from a relative a teacher or friend that really informed your life? Second proposal is considering that all those teachers were and are human. What is your relationship to the mistakes those teachers make? Because we all make mistakes, right? How do you relate to that? Are you one of those people who put up those teachers on a high pedestal and wait for them to topple or are you just acknowledging, yeah, teachers mess up too. So, let's have triads.

Thank you.



www.RedCedarZen.org     360-389-3444     registrar@redcedarzen.org
Powered by Wild Apricot Membership Software